Beyond the Highlight Reel: What Coaches Watch When the Ball Isn’t in Your Hands

Most athletes think their recruiting fate is sealed by the three-minute highlight video they sent out last month. We spend hours editing the perfect clips of our best goals, fastest sprints, or highest jumps. But here’s the reality: once a coach is interested in your physical skill, they stop looking at the ball and start looking at you. When a scout sits in the stands this spring, they aren’t just watching your scoring average; they are looking for the "invisible" work—the character traits that prove you’re a teammate worth investing in for the next four years.

This invisible work happens in the small, quiet moments of a game. It’s the energy you bring to a huddle when the team is down, showing that you’re locked in and making eye contact with your coach rather than scanning the stands for your friends. It’s how you react to failure. When you get subbed out after a tough mistake, a coach is watching to see if you pout on the end of the bench or if you’re the first one up cheering for the person who replaced you. They want to see the "dirty work"—the player who sprints back on defense after a turnover or dives for a loose ball when the game feels out of reach.

At the end of the day, your talent is what gets you on a coach's radar, but your character is what gets you the offer. Coaches are building a culture, not just a roster, and they need to know you’ll contribute to that culture even when the cameras aren't on you. As you head into your next game, play like the scout is focused solely on your body language and your effort between the plays. That is where the real recruiting happens.

Any questions? Email us at readysetgoathletes@gmail.com